Skulk wallwalking view rotation

Asraniel

So, the new patch has the slight view change when wallwalking as a skulk. Since beta is all about testing, lets see what people think about it.

I for one think that while it looks nice, it makes the skulk unplayable, at least if you wallwalk often. I really get sick after a short time, making it impossible to play a skulk for more than a few minutes.

So what do you think? does this go into the "nice idea, but not playable" category or could it be improved? Made optional?

ScardyBob

Make it optional so I can turn it off. It gets disorienting, especially in vents or other tight spaces.

Feha

I kind of like it, but it sould be optional, and I think it might be better if only the viewmodel rotate, not the actual camera (atm i am not always sure if I am on a wall because of no good horizon to tell me how angled i am).

Papayas

I love it!

Asraniel

<!--quoteo(post=1837593:date=Mar 17 2011, 08:47 PM:name=Feha)--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Feha @ Mar 17 2011, 08:47 PM) <a href="index.php?act=findpost&pid=1837593"><{POST_SNAPBACK}></a></div><div class='quotemain'><!--quotec-->I kind of like it, but it sould be optional, and I think it might be better if only the viewmodel rotate, not the actual camera (atm i am not always sure if I am on a wall because of no good horizon to tell me how angled i am).<!--QuoteEnd--></div><!--QuoteEEnd-->

That sounds like a good compromise

TAPETRVE

Nope, it's not a "compromise", it is an entirely useless cosmetical shenanigan. When it comes to latitude, it doesn't change a thing.

Asraniel

Could you elaborate?

My opionion is to either fix the effect, for example with the mentioned compromise, or remove it completely.
Having an option is not really a solution, most people won't find it etc. Having the viewmodel tilt, still achieves the goal of showing when you are wallwalking, but on the same time does not make you feel sick

SN.Wolf

The only issue i have with it is when inside vents. I could see a entity introduced in the editor to cancel out tilt/view so mappers can place these in vents or if it where possible to make the view tilt disable when space is smaller than x#/y#/z#.

It's not a huge issue and i do think it adds a certain immersion into the character, think onos momentum. It just fits.

Runteh

It does actually help, despite what people have said. Because of the angle of rotation when looking down on people from an angle, it gives you a better FOV because of the way the teeth align. It also means you can stay fairly parallel with the wall, so you don't have to turn yourself as much to see what is going on.

I think it is working really well, it might need a bit more tweaking as suggested with the vents, but it on its way to being complete. It certainly has more of an alien feel, and doesn't feel as much like I'm a entity stuck to a wall.

spellman23

Full View Rotation,if added in, should be optional.

View tilt seems cool and appears to be beneficial, but I haven't had a chance to try it out due to comp being borken.

OPIE

I like it. Then again I don't get any type of motion sickness and I guess it depends on the person but it doesn't seem disorientating to me at all. I never lose my barrings.

For me it gives the wall walking skulk feel more like I am indeed wall walking. Instead of the obvious of being 5-15 feet off the ground on the side of a wall or ceiling.

Hakujin

Given how many people complained about not having it in NS1, and the fact that it is implemented, I think it should remain as an option. Perhaps even the default option, since it helps "sell" the benefits of the custom game engine.

PersianImm0rtal

Its really nice I love it!

Heroman117

Its a really nice effect and for me its subtle enough that it doesn't bother me, though i guess for the people who get motion sickness very easily it should be an option to turn off.

Asraniel

Interesting discussion!

I expected that more people would feel sick using it like me. Now i don't know how much those that liked it actually used it, but it shows that every person is different.

So i think the best way to go is to have an option.

Shilorius

I admit I get a little sea sick but the view tilt is awesome!

<!--quoteo--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div><div class='quotemain'><!--quotec-->For me it gives the wall walking skulk feel more like I am indeed wall walking.<!--QuoteEnd--></div><!--QuoteEEnd-->
This

However I would prefer to have one of three options to choose:
- no rotation
- slightly rotation (default)
- full rotation


because judging by the posts here (not only in this thread) every option will have its fans.

TAPETRVE

<!--quoteo(post=1837758:date=Mar 18 2011, 12:29 PM:name=Shilorius)--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Shilorius @ Mar 18 2011, 12:29 PM) <a href="index.php?act=findpost&pid=1837758"><{POST_SNAPBACK}></a></div><div class='quotemain'><!--quotec-->However I would prefer to have one of three options to choose:
- no rotation
- slightly rotation (default)
- full rotation<!--QuoteEnd--></div><!--QuoteEEnd-->

I'm with you on that. The only problem I see is that full view rotation gives those who can use it a serious advantage in terms of movement restriction over those who don't. So maybe it should be marked as some kind of "pro" option, that can only be activated in matches where the host grants permission to use it. That would, of course, mean that the use of view rotation has to be considered in matchmaking.

NurEinMensch

Fully agree. Keep all 3 as an option, but keep in mind that full rotation is not just a gimmick, it affects game play because it allows for far more efficient movement.

danshyu

Well I'll have to say with view tilt it felt a lot easier to stay on the wall now.

GrapeVine

I like it very much, it adds a cool hangy feel when wallwalking but I can see how it can be disorienting for some people. They could make on/off option but I don't think they should add full rotation just because they can.

kingmob

I honestly did not notice the tilt playing as skulk.
I truly wish the stickiness reaches a point where walking on the ceiling is no problem.
and I jump or leap to detach.
But all these incremental improvements of skulk stickiness i love.

I actually hope they put the other camera (rotate with the model) in as an option.
Maybe after initial release.
Some people will like that.

They should throw that code in the 'maybe in the future' pile.

Evil_bOb1

I Love the tilting it gives a nice feel to the skulk.

Little things like this should be added to all classes, and i imagine that's what the plan is.

I don't think there should be the option to turn it off/different modes. It may need some tweaking so it is just barely noticeable yet still adds a lot to the feel. These effects for each life form will give each class a signature feel and its what makes NS2 a unique product. If they consider them as an option, its like saying this is <i>a</i> way you can play NS2 but its not really part of NS2. I think the devs have to be bold in their decisions and give a precise NS2 experience.