Since I've been accused of vagueness before, I'll try and elaborate:
I've already given a list of those I find more suspect than the rest, and BadKarma is on it. Sky isn't. While that doesn't mean I'm <i>right</i>, it's the best I can do with the info I have, to be honest.
Ever since I came back to my parents' house last Friday, I've had trouble staying on IRC. I'll join every now and again (especially at the beginning of a new Day), but I can't idle on there. If you want to speak to me in real time, send me a PM and we'll go from there.
I know I said I'd change if it looked like Badkarma was going to be killed, but I may have to revise that. Sky is being threatened by three people that picked him almost at random, and that doesn't sit well with me. I at least have a vague suspicion of Badkarma, so I'd prefer him to die instead of Sky, who I think is human.
BadKarmaThe Advanced Literature monsters burned my house and gave me a 7Join Date: 2002-11-12Member: 8260Members
People say that they are suspicious of me, I wouldnt mind hearing the reasoning behind that. Regardless, as in last game, I still lack a special role, so my death would be pretty trivial. If I die, im gonna die with my finger pointed at Snidely, ala Nem from last game.
I'm too tired to formulate a coherent post right now, and probably won't be up again until the day is over. Anyway, I wanted to say to Kerotan that he knows full and well what I'm talking about, its even in the Day 2 logs.
More importantly, I think killing Sky today would be a mistake - for starters, its just not making enough noise this close to an execution for him to be a wolf. And if he's very likely not a wolf, he's the last person we can afford to kill on a whim - he would be invaluable to a human network, if he hasn't yet been contacted. He's active and has experience with the endgame in what - at least 2 TWGs? (I might have to read up on my facts, could be more)
BadKarma, I have no clue about. I just know his avatar makes him look reaaaaally sinister.
ByekaName changed from Freak83TorontoJoin Date: 2003-03-13Member: 14484Members, Constellation
At this point I'm not even sure of who I'm suspicious of anymore. Although I'm switching to <b>Kerotan</b> to keep it even right now. I feel it would be worse for Sky to die right now when we're not sure if he's even a wolf.
If you really think that sky is not guilty, i will trust you with that freak, but i don´t agree at your point about kerotan, so i´ll change my vote to <b>BadKarma</b> instead
<!--QuoteBegin-Freak83+--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td><b>QUOTE</b> (Freak83)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'><!--QuoteEBegin-->Although I'm switching to Kerotan to keep it even right now. I feel it would be worse for Sky to die right now when we're not sure if he's even a wolf.<!--QuoteEnd--></td></tr></table><div class='postcolor'><!--QuoteEEnd--> I'm also curious: what makes Kerotan any more or less a wolf than Sky?
I'm now going to change my vote to <b>Zerobyte</b>, as Sky is safe now. This is a random vote, as I'm not sure enough to push Badkarma, Hellfire or Kerotan over the edge.
I see a sudden appearence of people glad to have Sky safe. Why is this? Does anyone have any information that makes Sky any less suspicious? Because otherwise, I'm tempted to change my mind.
Soul_RiderMod BeanJoin Date: 2004-06-19Member: 29388Members, Constellation, Squad Five Blue
OK, what the hell happened there? I go out for one night on the beer, come back and find everyone has jumped on my vote for sky in an effort to get him killed. Like i said i am convinced Sky is human, and so no-one causes me to be involved in a killing on someone like sky i will now move my vote.
I can't believe you guys did that. Sky is very obviously human, he argues too much to be anything else, so that makes me suspicious of the people who jumped onto his back.
I am still not convinced of any wolves so i will move my vote again to someone else who has no votes, seeing as people seem to be intent on putting sky at risk.
Going on my previous statements, <b>PlanetKiller</b> has no votes against him. I do not believe him to be a wolf, but i just don't feel like getting a phantom.
No hard feelings. And once again if anyone jumps on this i will change my vote.
<!--QuoteBegin-Soul Rider+May 8 2005, 01:19 PM--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td><b>QUOTE</b> (Soul Rider @ May 8 2005, 01:19 PM)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'><!--QuoteEBegin--> There is a debate going on, does Badkarma's vote for hellfire count? Was it missed or is it because he spelt his name wrong?
Please confirm because this changes the balance of things if he has got a second vote which isnt showing on the board. <!--QuoteEnd--> </td></tr></table><div class='postcolor'> <!--QuoteEEnd--> Yes, his vote does count. As long as i know what he means beyond all doubt, i will count the vote.
<!--QuoteBegin-Kerotan+May 8 2005, 11:28 AM--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td><b>QUOTE</b> (Kerotan @ May 8 2005, 11:28 AM)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'><!--QuoteEBegin--> oh and btw BadKama, nothing against you or anything but its a fish eat fish world... <!--QuoteEnd--> </td></tr></table><div class='postcolor'> <!--QuoteEEnd--> I wish I had sig space for that.
I'll have you all know that I am in contact with the seer. I was his first target. His second target, however, turned out to be a wolf. By his request, I reveal the truth: <b>Sky</b> is trying to get all the humans killed.
Comments
I've already given a list of those I find more suspect than the rest, and BadKarma is on it. Sky isn't. While that doesn't mean I'm <i>right</i>, it's the best I can do with the info I have, to be honest.
Snidely - 1 (ZeroByte)
Quaunaut - 1 (lolfighter)
BadKarma - 3 (i'm lost, PlanetKiller, Snidely)
lolfighter - 1 (Quaunaut)
im lost - 1 (BadKarma)
Hellfire3k - 2 (Kerotan, Sky)
Sky - 3 (Soul Rider, Pithlit, Freak83)
Kerotan - 2 (Xentor, Saltzbad)
Xentor - 1 (Hellfire3k)
if the last list was ok.
More importantly, I think killing Sky today would be a mistake - for starters, its just not making enough noise this close to an execution for him to be a wolf. And if he's very likely not a wolf, he's the last person we can afford to kill on a whim - he would be invaluable to a human network, if he hasn't yet been contacted. He's active and has experience with the endgame in what - at least 2 TWGs? (I might have to read up on my facts, could be more)
BadKarma, I have no clue about. I just know his avatar makes him look reaaaaally sinister.
Snidely - 1 (ZeroByte)
Quaunaut - 1 (lolfighter)
BadKarma - 3 (i'm lost, PlanetKiller, Snidely)
lolfighter - 1 (Quaunaut)
im lost - 1 (BadKarma)
Hellfire3k - 2 (Kerotan, Sky)
Sky - 2 (Soul Rider, Pithlit)
Kerotan - 3 (Xentor, Saltzbad, Freak83)
Xentor - 1 (Hellfire3k)
so could someone fill me in..
I'm also curious: what makes Kerotan any more or less a wolf than Sky?
Snidely - 1 (ZeroByte)
Quaunaut - 1 (lolfighter)
BadKarma - 4 (im lost, PlanetKiller, Snidely, Pithlit)
lolfighter - 1 (Quaunaut)
Hellfire3k - 3 (Kerotan, Sky, BadKarma)
Sky - 1 (Soul Rider)
Kerotan - 3 (Xentor, Saltzbad, Freak83)
Xentor - 1 (Hellfire3k)
I can't believe you guys did that. Sky is very obviously human, he argues too much to be anything else, so that makes me suspicious of the people who jumped onto his back.
I am still not convinced of any wolves so i will move my vote again to someone else who has no votes, seeing as people seem to be intent on putting sky at risk.
Going on my previous statements, <b>PlanetKiller</b> has no votes against him. I do not believe him to be a wolf, but i just don't feel like getting a phantom.
No hard feelings. And once again if anyone jumps on this i will change my vote.
Snidely - 1 (ZeroByte)
Quaunaut - 1 (lolfighter)
BadKarma - 3 (im lost, Snidely, Pithlit)
lolfighter - 1 (Quaunaut)
Hellfire3k - 3 (Kerotan, Sky, BadKarma)
PlanetKiller - 1 (Soul Rider)
Kerotan - 3 (Xentor, Saltzbad, Freak83)
Xentor - 1 (Hellfire3k)
Zerobyte - 1 (PlanetKiller)
Please confirm because this changes the balance of things if he has got a second vote which isnt showing on the board.
Please confirm because this changes the balance of things if he has got a second vote which isnt showing on the board. <!--QuoteEnd--> </td></tr></table><div class='postcolor'> <!--QuoteEEnd-->
Yes, his vote does count. As long as i know what he means beyond all doubt, i will count the vote.
too save my own skin...
If ppl want reasons, well for once it would be a 2 way tie anyway if xentor didnt do a random vote on me instead off a 3 way... so yea
Quaunaut - 1 (lolfighter)
BadKarma - 4 (im lost, Snidely, Pithlit, Kerotan)
lolfighter - 1 (Quaunaut)
Hellfire3k - 2 (Sky, BadKarma)
PlanetKiller - 1 (Soul Rider)
Kerotan - 3 (Xentor, Saltzbad, Freak83)
Xentor - 1 (Hellfire3k)
Zerobyte - 1 (PlanetKiller)
I wish I had sig space for that.
Snidely: Considering at least two votes against Sky were randoms, it seems rather silly to vote him out with zero evidence.
Someone has to be voted out, evidence or no.